One of the benefits of being a member of the International Association of Business Communicators (IABC) is the bi-monthly magazine, CW.
Every other month, the printed publication originally known as Communication World would come through your letterbox filled with useful and highly-readable content that offered knowledge, insight, interviews, case studies, how-to features and a host of articles addressing issues, trends and the actualities of modern communication management, internal and external, as practiced by people across the world.
In my two-plus decades of IABC membership, I regarded CW as among the top three most valuable member benefits, alongside professional development and member connectivity. I was an occasional contributor to the magazine for a number of years since the early 90s.
Some months ago, it emerged that IABC would cease publication of the printed CW and offer it only in digital form. On May 14, IABC announced the first edition of the new CW digital that will be published monthly, available on desktop, mobile and iOS devices with an Android version coming (and which is now available).
[…] “The great thing about going completely digital is that Communication World will be available to download anywhere — on your smartphone, computer or tablet. And all the content is shareable with a tap of your finger, even video,” said Natasha Nicholson, executive editor for Communication World. “Having CW available as an interactive app is going to create a much better, more interactive experience for the reader.”
One of the main reasons the magazine went completely digital was because some overseas members of IABC wouldn’t receive their copies for several weeks after mailing, making the content far less timely. Nicholson explains that by going digital, everyone will be able to receive each issue as soon as it becomes available.
There’s more to IABC’s news, too. For the next four months, IABC says that CW digital will be free of charge to anyone.
[…] the magazine will be available to anyone in the world for free for the next four months (until the end of September 2013), at which time the subscription will continue to be free to members while non-members will pay $119 per year or $12.99 per issue.
I think this is a great move by IABC although I can imagine the complete shutdown of the print publication won’t be easy for some members to warmly embrace.
Part of winning those hearts and minds to the new-format CW will be what the “CW digital experience” is like, one that ought to be utterly compelling so that you don’t really miss not having the paper magazine in your hands.
I would define “utterly compelling” as a combination of things like these:
- Great content which, in IABC’s case, can literally go without saying.
- Easy access and seamless retrieval of each edition, whether that’s downloading or reading on the website.
- Mobile apps that not only aid the pleasurable content-consumption experience but also enable and encourage reader/author/publisher engagement.
Based on my experience with this first edition of CW digital, the content is unquestionably terrific! However, IABC has some major work to do with the other two items I’ve mentioned.
Some screenshots illustrate what I experienced.
Accessing CW digital from the link in IABC’s press release produced a visual mess in my default Chrome browser on a Windows 7 desktop computer.
I just couldn’t get that menu to reduce or minimize or whatever so that I could see the content itself. Maybe a glitch at the time I accessed the publication. But it did this every time I tried it.
The only success I got was using Internet Explorer. It’s not a browser I ever use unless I have to…
Not a good start.
I decided to download the publication from the download link at the top right of the screen display. Clicking it produced a little window telling me that a 4-meg PDF would download. Another click to begin, and the magazine arrived.
To be honest, the last thing I ever want to do is read a publication as a PDF file on a computer. It’s not an experience I associate with a good time. One option I have is to load it onto my Kindle ebook reader. What would be great, though, is if IABC made a version for Kindle available. Easy to do.
What strikes me most about these steps – apart from the hurdle-jumping I had to do – is how the digital magazine looks just like content output from a print-publishing system. It’s what CW was like before.
Maybe that’s part of the plan but it seems to me that something huge is missing in the evolution to digital only: look at the example of what Atlantic Media has done with Quartz magazine.
I have Android mobile devices so I was very interested when the news came that the Android app was available. I thought I’d install it on my Android tablet, a Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 LTE from EE, running Android version 4.1.2.
When I went to get the app from Google Play on the tablet, imagine my surprise and disappointment to see the message “Your device isn’t compatible with this version.”
I tried again, this time from a Samsung Galaxy SII smartphone also running Android 4.1.2.
Success this time. But the app offered me a confusing and unsatisfactory experience, starting with being given choices that suggest I need to subscribe or at least pay for the issue (it’s supposed to be free until September, remember?).
In summary, CW digital has great content. It’s a good move by IABC to migrate its flagship publication to a digital format, for the reasons they mention in their announcement (and others, too, I imagine, eg, cost savings).
Yet the poor execution of the platform isn’t a good start and, in my view, is a major impediment to gaining enthusiastic adoption of the new publication that now has no alternative form.
I look at it this way: IABC has three months to listen to feedback and get it right – to aim for that utterly compelling experience – before charging kicks in in September.
[Note: I was an active IABC member for 23 years until last November, so I’m currently a lapsed member. I have critical opinions about IABC and its current leadership. None of that has influenced anything I’ve written in this post about CW; I’m mentioning this fact purely for transparency.]
Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/yipzZm34n5
RT @jangles: Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/VZd5gkWDwe <JC: An interesting read!
RT @jangles: Content is king but so is the delivery platform: One of the benefits of being a member of the International Asso… http://t.…
Matt O’Neill liked this on Facebook.
Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/u2oKJpNxSG
Hobson: Content is king but so is the delivery platform: One of the benefits of being a member of the Internat… http://t.co/5USyLsYwV6
RT @jangles: Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/yipzZm34n5
I’m preparing for a flight to Tbilisi (Georgia) tomorrow and was just preparing some in-flight reading material when I remembered your tweet about the free three months. Tried to install it on my tablet and had exactly the same experience. OK I can still read the PDF on my tablet, but I wanted the app as I expected it would provide me with something ‘extra’.
I don’t have any desire to read it on my smaller mobile screen (even if my S4 has a larger screen than most).
Ironically, one reason I wanted to read it as when I do training overseas I’m sometimes asked about the value of membership of different communications organisations. My knowledge of the IABC is mainly based on what I’ve heard you and Shel Holtz say so I thought reading the magazine would give me a better insight.
It’s a shame, Stuart, that your introduction to IABC’s stellar content is not a good one. As our similar experiences clearly indicate, you can have the best content there is but if getting at is is such a pain, all is for nought. Indeed, the poor experiences becomes the (negative) story.
What type of tablet were you using? This will help us to develop a solution.
It’s not just me complaining about @iabc Communication World app, so is long-time, but now lapsed, member @jangles http://t.co/9skQBENAoZ
Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/rnArix8wUb
RT @mostash: Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/rnArix8wUb
MT@stuartbruce: Not just me complaining about @iabc Communication World app @jangles http://t.co/bTmh7kcCSO > how did it pass beta testing?
RT @jangles: Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/Pk1nl9nsS7 <- The platform is only as good as its user experience
Content is king but so is the delivery platform: http://t.co/9VGA4XrcCw via @jangles
Indeed, I like horseradish, delivered by oysters. “@mostash: Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/28EC9Zic80“
Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/5L1dIGYqoA
Margie Capewell liked this on Facebook.
Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/WEJ5eNFIfp
RT @jangles: Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/tUKQjpSpeM @stc_org
Thanks for taking the time for this review of CW digital. I couldn’t agree more regarding the criteria you outlined for the magazine – both in terms of content and delivery. It’s my intent to make sure we live up to that! We’ve done a lot of testing, but it looks like a few bugs have surfaced. I’m checking into them and will touch base soon.
Here are a couple of things I can share now. When you’re looking at the browser version on a mobile device, touch the “T” to view it in text mode – otherwise as you said it looks like a shrunken version of the magazine.
And here’s some clarification about public access. The browser version of the magazine is available to the public for four months. The apps are free to download and include a demo – but full access to the magazine through the apps requires a member login. So, the magazine content is free for everyone right now, but the apps are fee-based.
I’ll be back with more info as soon as I have it. In the meantime, here’s a link to the FAQs: http://www.iabc.com/webarticles/2013/0513/CWDigitalFAQs.htm
Also, here’s what one digital news agency said about the iPad app version: http://talkingnewmedia.blogspot.com/2013/04/association-launches-simple-effective.html
Natasha,many thanks for sharing your thoughts, I appreciate it.
Thank you for clarifying the situation re access from the mobile apps (subscription based, not free) and access via the browser (open to all and free for 4 months). The disappointing experience I had on a mobile device and not being able to access the content now makes sense. It would have been good to have known that beforehand although I see the FAQ you link to has the info. I didn’t know about that FAQ until now.
I saw that review you mention. As you noted, it was a review of the app for iPad. I’ve heard good things from iPad users. Not yet from Android tablet users.
“Content is king but so is the delivery platform http://t.co/mvGnSodDlJ” from @jangles – publishers need to keep their audience in mind.
I’m back with more info. We’re working with our digital provider and I have some answers. On the Chrome issue, they (and a number of us here on staff) have been unable to replicate the weird problem you’re having with that. Can you tell me what version you’re using? That would help us to figure this out.
On the Google Play issue, here is the word back on that. They have just uploaded a new version to the Google Play store, which is now ready. They suggest that users try downloading the app again now that the update is live. Can you give that a try?
If you or others continue to have trouble, in addition to knowing what kind of device you are using we need to know the version of the Android operating system you’re using (e.g. 2.3.6). That will help the developer team either create a fix or provide instructions about which OS versions support the app.
Thanks for your patience (and effort) as we try to work the bugs out. I really appreciate it!
Thanks Natasha, I appreciate your looking into that.
As for the Chrome browser issue I experienced, it must have been a glitch at the moment I tried it (I mentioned that possibility in the post). I just upgraded Chrome on the desktop PC to the latest version released yesterday; can’t remember the previous version number now!
Great news re the app. I’ll try it again on my tablet, will report back here how that goes.